Alternative Africa

Top Menu

  • Home
  • About Us
  • Privacy Policy
  • Terms of Use
  • Contact Us

Main Menu

  • Home
  • Arts & Culture
  • Business
  • Environment
  • Politics
  • Sports
  • Reports
    • Africa-Observers
      • Read Reports
      • Submit a story
  • MORE
    • Health
    • News Now
    • World
    • Technology
Sign in / Join

Login

Welcome! Login in to your account
Lost your password?

Lost Password

Back to login
  • Home
  • About Us
  • Privacy Policy
  • Terms of Use
  • Contact Us

logo

Alternative Africa

  • Home
  • Arts & Culture
  • Business
  • Environment
  • Politics
  • Sports
  • Reports
    • Africa-Observers
      • Read Reports
      • Submit a story
  • MORE
    • Health
    • News Now
    • World
    • Technology
  • Seven captured Nigerian school girls escape from abductors

  • Africa could expand economy by staggering $1.5 trillion with Artificial Intelligence

  • WHO-led consortium launches Covid-19-Oxygen Emergency Taskforce to address shortages

  • GIZ, Orange inaugurate third Digital Centre in Ethiopia

  • UNECA puts young African students on the path of Artificial intelligence technology

News NowWorld
Home›News Now›‘Black Day’ protests to mark demonetisation anniversary

‘Black Day’ protests to mark demonetisation anniversary

By alternativeafrica
November 8, 2017
673
0
Share:

New Delhi, India – Opposition parties in India have called for street protests to mark one year since the government of Prime Minister Narendra Modi banned high denomination banknotes in a stated attempt to target undeclared “black” money and fight corruption.

At least 18 opposition parties, including the Indian National Congress, will mark the anniversary as a “Black Day”, accusing the government of harming the country’s economy with its policies.

“Demonetisation achieved nothing. Hence, we are observing November 8 as a Black Day,” said Palaniappan Chidambaram, former finance minister of the Congress party, which ruled between 2004 and 2014.

“Demonetisation was illegal. It violated many laws and cases are pending before the Supreme Court,” he told Al Jazeera.

Prime Minister Modi personally led the shock move on November 8 last year to outlaw 86 percent of the cash in circulation, making the announcement via a televised address.

{articleGUID}

The old tenders of 500 ($7.73) and 1,000 rupees ($15.45) became illegal within hours of Modi’s announcement.

Indians only had months to exchange the old notes for new ones.

Demonetisation was illegal. It violated many laws and cases are pending before the Supreme Court

Palaniappan Chidambaram, former finance minister of the Congress party

The government expected that a large amount of black money would not make it back, and therefore would be wiped from the system.

But the Reserve Bank of India said in August that 99 percent of the estimated $242bn in high-currency bills were returned, leading to questions regarding the efficacy of the exercise.

Chidambaram said that there were suspicions that demonetisation was a device to help people with unaccounted, or black, money to convert it into accounted “white” money.

Subhasini Ali, a Politburo member of the Communist Party of India, said the project was a “cruel attack” on the people of this country.

{articleGUID}

The left parties, including Ali’s CPI, have joined the protest.

“This was the most devious, dishonest and anti-people step that any government could have taken,” Ali told Al Jazeera. “The day the people fully understand what this note ban was all about, I think there will not be much future for the BJP [Bharatiya Janata Party] any more.”

The ruling party has defended its move, saying the main aims of demonetisation – fighting corruption and “black money” – have been achieved.

“There are many successes of demonetisation,” said Nalin Kohli, spokesperson for the ruling BJP, as she began to list them. “Encouraging people to go cashless, [boosting] tax compliance and simultaneously identifying suspicious accounts and transactions that will enable boost future tax collection while taking action against the guilty.” 

Chaos and queues

The decision, which was widely criticised by economists and media at home and abroad, caused utter chaos as people spent months lining up to swap old notes for new.

As the prime minister asked Indians to be patient, many faced hunger and even death. According to reports, about 100 people, mostly elderly, died of exhaustion while waiting in bank queues across the country.

But in what could be interpreted as continued support for the prime minister, the right-wing ruling party won elections in the politically key state of Uttar Pradesh in March by riding on Modi’s high popularity.



Several people fell ill, and some elderly Indians died as they waited in line for new money [Showkat Shafi/Al Jazeera]

Even as criticism mounts, the defiant premier insists he will not relent in his avowed fight for the poor against the rich.

“A few people who faced the heat of demonetisation are still complaining and are planning to observe November 8 [with protests]. The Congress cannot scare me by burning my effigies,” the Indian Prime Minister said on Sunday.

“My fight against corruption will not stop,” he declared as people applauded at an election campaign rally in the northern Himalayan state of Himachal Pradesh.

A year later, official data around demonetisation is still sketchy. The central bank says it is still verifying the returned notes.

India’s cash-dependent unorganised sector – which forms more than 80 percent of the economy – suffered badly, leading to factory closures and job losses.

For small businesses in the rural areas, it is practically impossible to make payments digitally, when both power outages and lack of internet connectivity hampers work

HP Yadav, president of National Capital Region Chamber of Commerce and Industry

President of the National Capital Region Chamber of Commerce and Industry, HP Yadav, says micro and small industries have “suffered a lot” during and after the shock move with most firms downsizing by an average of around 20 percent.

He also argued against forcing digitisation for small businesses – a key government goal.

“One year after this was announced, our view is that a company or an individual must have freedom to choose cash or digital mode of payment. For small businesses in the rural areas, it is practically impossible to make payments digitally, when both power outages and lack of internet connectivity hampers work,” Yadav told Al Jazeera.

Before the government’s planned celebrations, an Indian minister, Jayant Sinha, on Monday described the note ban as “a resounding success”.

“When revolutionary changes take place, it takes years, decades, or even centuries before the effect of such transformations can be studied and commented upon,” he wrote in the Indian daily, Mint.

‘No real data’

Economists have questioned the government’s claims.

“We have no real data on whether the tax base has actually expanded beyond the trend increase that was already occurring before the move,” said Jayati Ghosh, professor of economics at Jawaharlal Nehru University in New Delhi.

“There are many areas and parts of the economy that have still not recovered even to pre-demonetisation levels of activity,” she said.

{articleGUID}

Reetika Khera, an economist also based in New Delhi, said the government was not clear about what it wanted to achieve.

“Whether it was a measure against corruption, or to expand the tax base, or to increase digitisation by reducing reliance on cash, none of these objectives required demonetisation,” she said.

These objectives could have been better achieved through other reform measures, she explained, such as strengthening the tax authorities and taking action against defaulters.

“Demonetisation hurt the economy in the short run [and possibly in the longer run as well], and caused unnecessary hardship, especially to ordinary citizens,” Khera told Al Jazeera.

Spillover slowdown from the note ban saw an immediate fall in gross domestic product (GDP). Growth slid to a three-year low in the last quarter of 2016.

{articleGUID}

A Reuters poll in October said a majority of economists believe India’s economy will likely grow at its slowest pace in four years this fiscal year, particularly because of the disruptive effect of demonetisation.

“None of the three declared objectives of demonetisation – stamping out black money, ending corruption and ending counterfeiting – has been achieved,” said Chidambaram, the former finance minister of the Congress party.

“The decline in GDP from 7.0 percent [in the third quarter of last year] to 5.7 [in the first quarter of this year] has cost the economy 100,000 crore ($15.45 billion) in a period of six months. The annualised cost will be higher.

“Millions of jobs in the informal sector were lost. Daily wage earners were pushed into penury and devastated.”

But Prime Minister Modi remains unfazed by the criticism.

On Sunday, he boasted that 300,000 companies have shut down after demonetisation and a probe into the financial dealings of 5,000 such firms revealed massive fraud.

India’s opposition parties have failed to mount a credible challenge to Prime Minister Modi since he came to power in a 2014 landslide vote.

With events such as the Black Day protests on November 8, opposition parties are attempting to shift the narrative from a clash of personalities – where Modi is a clear winner – to a debate about the government policies.



The old tenders of 500 ($7.73) and 1,000 rupees ($15.45) became illegal within hours of Modi’s announcement last November [Showkat Shafi/Al Jazeera]
SHARE ON:
TagsBreakingNewsWorld
Previous Article

Saudi Arabia and Iran in war of ...

Next Article

Italy arrests Libyan, Egyptian over death of ...

0
Shares
  • 0
  • +
  • 0
  • 0
  • 0
  • 0

alternativeafrica

Related articles More from author

  • News Now

    Nigeria’s Ahmed Musa faces uncertain future at Leicester City

    December 29, 2017
    By alternativeafrica
  • News Now

    Slimani stunner helps Leicester to win

    September 19, 2017
    By alternativeafrica
  • News NowWorld

    UN’s Guterres urges Kurds in Iraq to scrap referendum

    September 17, 2017
    By alternativeafrica
  • News NowWorld

    SIGAR report puts Afghan security deficiencies in focus

    September 22, 2017
    By alternativeafrica
  • News Now

    Africa’s year in pictures 2017

    December 29, 2017
    By alternativeafrica
  • News NowWorld

    Earthquake kills more than 200 in central Mexico

    September 20, 2017
    By alternativeafrica

Leave a reply Cancel reply

This site uses Akismet to reduce spam. Learn how your comment data is processed.

You might be interested

  • AfricaHealthNews Now

    Africa exceeds 3 million covid-19 cases, 72,000 deaths

  • AfricaNews NowPolitics

    After Nigeria, another West African country, Senegal goes to poll on Sunday

  • AfricaBusinessNews Now

    Africa launches dedicated networking platform to connect 50 million women in business

Timeline

  • February 27, 2021

    Seven captured Nigerian school girls escape from abductors

  • February 27, 2021

    Africa could expand economy by staggering $1.5 trillion with Artificial Intelligence

  • February 27, 2021

    WHO-led consortium launches Covid-19-Oxygen Emergency Taskforce to address shortages

  • February 26, 2021

    GIZ, Orange inaugurate third Digital Centre in Ethiopia

  • February 26, 2021

    UNECA puts young African students on the path of Artificial intelligence technology

  • Popular

  • Comments

  • Lagos govt confirms first case of deadly coronavirus infection in Nigeria

    By alternativeafrica
    February 28, 2020
  • Keynote Address of President Nana Addo Dankwa Akufo-Addo at 2018 Oxford Africa Conference

    By PSJ Africa
    May 14, 2018
  • Morocco begins regional integration by connecting Casablanca Airport with High Speed Train

    By alternativeafrica
    January 4, 2020
  • Kenyan govt pressure Facebook for data on Kenyan users

    By alternativeafrica
    November 20, 2019
  • Nigeria: 32,000 capacity Lagos rice mill to start production in 2020

    By alternativeafrica
    December 23, 2019
  • Ado zagi
    on
    January 12, 2021

    Nigeria: EFCC Academy to begin award of degree

    Diploma leave areply from
  • Ethiopia joins Africa's Artificial Intelligence revolution | Alternative Africa
    on
    October 2, 2020

    Spending on Artificial Intelligence Systems in Africa, Middle East to top $374 million in 2020

    […] Many African countries ...
  • The 5 most popular Africans 2020
    on
    September 25, 2020

    Celebrating Congolese doctor Jean-Jacques Muyembe, the man behind breakthrough of Ebola cure

    […] Dr. Jean-Jacques Muyembe ...
  • Millitants in Central Mali Set Jail Ablaze in Attack Killing Two | taktik(z) GDI (Government Defense ...
    on
    August 11, 2020

    Fifteen gendarmes killed in another attack on Mali camp

    […] attack fol­lowed a January ...
  • Millitants in Central Mali Set Jail Ablaze in Attack Killing Two
    on
    August 11, 2020

    Fifteen gendarmes killed in another attack on Mali camp

    […] attack followed a ...
AlternativeAfrica.com is an independent Pan African News Website dedicated primarily to influencing the negative narratives about Africa. We hope to do this by focusing and showcasing the many developmental strides sweeping across the continent.

Read more >>>

Contact Info

  • info@alternativeafrica.com
  • Recent

  • Popular

  • Comments

  • Seven captured Nigerian school girls escape from abductors

    By alternativeafrica
    February 27, 2021
  • Africa could expand economy by staggering $1.5 trillion with Artificial Intelligence

    By alternativeafrica
    February 27, 2021
  • WHO-led consortium launches Covid-19-Oxygen Emergency Taskforce to address shortages

    By alternativeafrica
    February 27, 2021
  • GIZ, Orange inaugurate third Digital Centre in Ethiopia

    By alternativeafrica
    February 26, 2021
  • Lagos govt confirms first case of deadly coronavirus infection in Nigeria

    By alternativeafrica
    February 28, 2020
  • Keynote Address of President Nana Addo Dankwa Akufo-Addo at 2018 Oxford Africa Conference

    By PSJ Africa
    May 14, 2018
  • Macron in Ivory Coast to launch anti-terrorism academy

    By alternativeafrica
    December 21, 2019
  • Kenyan govt pressure Facebook for data on Kenyan users

    By alternativeafrica
    November 20, 2019
  • Ado zagi
    on
    January 12, 2021

    Nigeria: EFCC Academy to begin award of degree

    Diploma leave areply from
  • Ethiopia joins Africa's Artificial Intelligence revolution | Alternative Africa
    on
    October 2, 2020

    Spending on Artificial Intelligence Systems in Africa, Middle East to top $374 million in 2020

    […] Many African countries ...
  • The 5 most popular Africans 2020
    on
    September 25, 2020

    Celebrating Congolese doctor Jean-Jacques Muyembe, the man behind breakthrough of Ebola cure

    […] Dr. Jean-Jacques Muyembe ...
  • Millitants in Central Mali Set Jail Ablaze in Attack Killing Two | taktik(z) GDI (Government Defense ...
    on
    August 11, 2020

    Fifteen gendarmes killed in another attack on Mali camp

    […] attack fol­lowed a January ...

Photostream

    Follow us

    • Home
    • About Us
    • Privacy Policy
    • Terms of Use
    • Contact Us
    © Copyright Alternative Africa 2019. All rights reserved.